Let down by agile

As a scrum master, agile coach type one of the key skills is working with people and teams facilitating their self organisation. This isn’t easy people are a tricky subject, they are all different and require different approaches. Looking for tools to help with this one book i read last year was Patrick Lencioni’s book Five Dysfunctions of a team.

 

screen-shot-2015-02-21-at-3-37-24-pm

Luckily for us agile frameworks give us a lot of the tools out of the box which help with these dysfunctions. The title of this post agile is letting us down is due to the lack of obvious Agile Cures for the two lower most steps of the pyramid. The base, the foundations, that seems pretty important.

 

img_5579

 

As Scrum Masters we get 14 hours of classroom based training and a multiple choice exam. Nothing is taught about the people skills how to do the job of a coach a people person, this is learnt on the job. Agile is letting us down because is doesn’t teach us anything about how to build trust in teams or work with conflict. We need to learn this for ourselves.

 

Agile frameworks do give us many things which help to cure the dysfunctions of a team.

Lack of commitment – Deadlines, effectively Timeboxes, sprints and sprint goals which with a facilitator work towards team commitment. Scrum is a commitment based framework.

Avoidance of accountability – Simple and Regular reviews giving us a continuous performance review process. Publication of Goals, big visible sprint goals.

Inattention to results – Sprint review meetings to analyse decisions made during the sprint. Retrospectives similarly to allow the team to review the sprint and generate insights.

We need to learn as coaches, scrum masters, captains:

Fear of conflict – TKI conflict modes, leading with real time permission and diagnosis of types of conflict. De difference between consensus and buy in.

Absence of Trust – Personal histories questions as a retro opener, improv games (last pic on your phone) Myers Briggs, Belbin people profiles

 

You could argue that if you manage deliver results using an agile framework the top step of the pyramid the bottom two will follow. I think the skill you have as a facilitator or coach at those two levels and even if you are seen to be delivering there will still be conflict and may still be an absence of trust which is stopping your team from reaching a truly performing level.

 

I want to see more agile coaching and training focusing on building team trust and dealing with conflict.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Let down by agile

  1. Thanks Stephen, very interesting. I’d agree and hope that keeping the top three levels well looked after would naturally reduce the need for the bottom two. Would the title ‘conflict’ be better shown as ‘Harmony’? to keep all titles the positive representations.

    With the bottom two levels a quick look at Graves Levels can show how complex it can become ‘http://vievolve.com/values-systems-4/’.

    I tend to find that clear roles and responsibilities and a good leader (not hero!) are the factors which alone have the biggest single positive influence.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s